About Me

My photo
DR WILFRED MONTEIRO (www.synergymanager.net) Mumbai INDIA- professor , nationally renowned thought leader & innovator of management practices, seminar speaker, consultant to board of directorsDR WILFRED MONTEIRO is India’s famed boardroom thought leader to guide innovative managment practices and business excellence models to build Peak Performance Organisations He founded Synergy Management Associates (www.synergymanager.net) in 1993 as a center for promoting business excellence through its training and consulting services. He is, a distinguished professor of Strategic Leadership and Organisation Development at India’d premier management institutes & chambers of commerce and a keynote speaker for numerous international conferences. He is a life coach & mentor to India’s business scions and young entrepreneurs He has fostered THOUGHT LEADERSHIP through over 2250 public seminars and conferences organised by the Confederation of Indian Industry, Bombay Chamber, Indian Merchants Chamber,Indian Institute of Management MACCIA etc

Saturday, 14 September 2019

CEO KNOWS EVERYTHING SYNDROME .



CAN SUCCESS MAKE
 A CEO  SELF DECEPTIVE?
Arrogance often threatens a CEO.
 If he also comes to believe that the CEO title grants infallibility, watch out!!!

Repeated studies have concluded one characteristic of powerful and successful leaders is high levels of self-confidence. Unfortunately, the researchers say, the higher the self-confidence, the less likely these leaders are open to advice and feedback.
CEO KNOWS EVERYTHING SYNDROME .

Arrogance often threatens a CEO. If he also comes to believe that the CEO title grants infallibility, watch out.  “Because I am CEO, I must know the business better than anyone else.” It has been said, but it just isn’t true. No CEO can be an expert in all functional areas. A CEO who is doing her job is spending time with the big picture. If he knows the details better than his employees, he’s either hiring the wrong people or spending his time at the wrong levels of the organization. It’s appropriate for a CEO to manage operations if absolutely necessary, but he should quickly hire good operational managers and return to leading the whole business.

CEOS CAN STOP LEARNING WELL.

Of course, once infallible, there’s no more to learn, and a CEO may quietly stop learning. Without daily oversight and high quality feedback on how he does the  job, he can mistakenly believe his actions lead to success. In reality, he may be doing the wrong thing, but his staff may be working around the clock to cover for his.

OPPORTUNITY IS LIKE THE ICEBERG
A CEO who does an adequate job, but far less than he could/should have done—goes unnoticed. Missed opportunities don’t get noticed... a 1000 crore rupee could have been a 5000 crore rupee company but this not never looked upon as a failure...which is flaunted that the 1000crore company was a personal achievement of the CEO Missed opportunities are sins of omissions of a CEO. Can they be  highlighted?

Setting vision is the CEO’s job, but nothing tells his if his sights are too low. He isn’t penalized for missing the grander vision. Such sins of omissions are a CEO’s worst enemy. He can be lulled into mediocrity by not knowing what would have been possible. Many inventions & technological breakthroughs were considered impossible…until someone ran it. Now, it’s commonplace. Likewise, a CEO may limit himself by not realizing he can do her job better.

 HONEST  FEEDBACK IS DANGEROUS?
They also make the point that powerful leaders seldom get useful feedback in their organizations. Nobody wants to take the risk especially with a dominating personality type. Subordinates are loath to give bad news or critical feedback (in any organization upward feedback is anti-gravity and does not more upward) and many boards are not diligent in seeing feedback for performance improvement, particularly relationships, as important as other things, such as financial results.

WHY IS THIS LEADERSHIP CRISIS HAPPENING?
The biggest leadership crises is the gap between how leaders see themselves and how others see them. Call it self-awareness. These blind spots can be limiting the possibilities of growth beyond the glass ceiling. The wider the gap, the more resistance there is to change. It also makes it difficult to create a positive organizational culture where openness and honesty are not encouraged.
Good leaders make people around them successful. They are passionate and committed, authentic, courageous, honest and reliable. But in today's high-pressure environment, leaders need a confidante, a mentor, or someone they can trust to tell the truth about their behavior. They rarely get that from employees and infrequently from board members.

THE FOUR  HIDDEN PERILS OF BEING AT THE TOP
 Based on my experience here is a few of the confessions of   CEO’s of what he experienced at important inflection points in their  career at the top...
1.    Life is lonely at the top: I do not have friends at work. I am an introvert (believe it or not), but that does not explain it all. I cannot sound my nascent ideas before my heads-of –department. I would be exposing myself to ridicule and appear weak before them
2.    Building consensus in  decision making: In my opinion, the higher you get as a manager the more decisions you have to make… But the tougher they are. when a manager really decides, not everyone will agree with the decision. Thus, “having everyone happy” and building consensus is important since their buy-in is need to implement the decision.
3.    Giving Feedback is Hard:  Part of a CEO’s job is to point out the behaviors that need to change; which, at least for me, is quite difficult. I remember a specific case: We had a very good conversation until I asked this person to change a behavior that I saw several times. The answer was pure denial, “But I always do it the way you suggest, I do not need to change”. Leading needs patience.
4.    CEO has nowhere to hide:  After several years leading I understood (yes, I am sometimes slow) that a lot of people are watching. A lot. That my agenda and my calendar must be transparent and coherent with my words. That if people are important for me, I have to spend time with people, and not hiding behind my PC. That my concerns are visible in my face, and people draw conclusions. That there will be rumors. And that most of the time they will against the cause I stand for.

CONCLUDING
Many suggest that a CEO needs a coach....to hasten the pace of learning; to crystallize the decision making process; to resolve decision dilemmas; to ensure direct and even blunt feedback  This really  summarizes the self-awareness and self-analytical approach to role improvement for a CEO
However will your CEO admit he needs a coach??? Why do CEO’s at the peak of their career and battle-hardened by experience and trial need a coach? Previous generations managed without them. Is coaching just another fad; which will eventually fade away? If a CEO openly admits he formally has a coach will he be considered inadequate and immature? Questions like this zoom in your mind! Having a coach is like having a soulmate. He is able to drive you at the difficult dilemmas all top level people face and have no one to talk to
The greatest quality great CEO’S must have...HUMILITY AFTER SUCCESS IS A UNKNOWN QUALITY... it happened to French emperor Napolean; the Shah of Iran  and the pages of history show umpteen cases of leaders who dug their own grave after success gave them a notion of infallibility
"I don't understand ..."
Similar to the pursuit of truth, good leaders also pursue understanding. Someone without good moral character might just pretend to understand as a way to move on. There's a curiosity to good leadership, and having character that says, "I want to understand the right answer ... always."
"That's a great idea ..."
Honest leaders won't ever steal an idea and make it their own. They recognize when someone on the team comes up with something worthwhile and gives due credit.
"I'm sorry ..."
Great leaders know how to apologize. It is part of their DNA. If they make a mistake, instead of pretending it's not a big deal or casting blame, they own up to the mistake
“I need to learn...”
Great CEO never stop learning by asking, listening and reading; they don’t feel embarrassed to ask their peers or suborindates for ideas; the don’t pretend to be know-alls or fake attention when other try to share new ideas. A powerful statement is “ I don’t know you tell me...”

With best  compliments
Dr Wilfred Monteiro
  




Wednesday, 18 October 2017

A good strategy is figuring out the best formula or mix across these four dimensions for generating the most profitable and potentially profitable business.

FIVE STEPS TO MAKE YOUR STRATEGIC PLANNING EFFECTIVE





Successful companies as they expand, and experience some initial success,  lose sight of their overall business strategy and end up wasting time, energy and money chasing after the wrong business.

They may also miss seeing the signs of change and stick to a strategy that is no longer viable in the marketplace. Here is a simple and effective method for defining your company’s strategy and ensuring that your company is pursuing the most profitable business.

STEP 1. Defining Your Company's Strategy
Your business strategy is determining your company’s scope or reaches across the following dimensions within your company’s marketplace:
  • the market segments or niches your company can and does serve;
  • the customer needs your company can and does fulfill (or products and services you company can and does offer);
  • the distribution methods that your company can and does utilize to get your products/service to the marketplace (e.g., direct to end users, via intermediary retailers or wholesalers, etc.);
  • the geographic territories where your business can and does exist (e.g., local, regional, national or international).
A good strategy is figuring out the best formula or mix across these four dimensions for generating the most profitable and potentially profitable business. Your strategy also positions your company in relation to its marketplace allies/partners and rivals/competitors. It makes little sense to work with customers, products, services, distribution channels, or in territories where there is little hope for current or future profit, thus company sustainability.

STEP 2 Developing Your Company’s Strategy

To develop part your company’s strategy, you can categorize your business’s market segments and product/service offerings and then create a "product/market matrix" (with market segments on the horizontal-axis, and product/service categories on the vertical-axis).

For example, one -Capital Goods marketing & maintenance company in New Delhi ( who  have been our recent client) created their matrix by segmenting its marketplace into A) brand new Capital Goods owners (those having Capital Goods less than one year), and B) existing Capital Goods owners (everyone else with a Capital Goods). They then differentiated their product/service offerings into 1) first-time Capital Goods startup, 2) ongoing Capital Goods maintenance services, 3) providing Capital Goods consumables, and 4) Capital Goods upgradation or decommissioning.

It is important to identify the specific cells in your company’s product/market matrix where there is greatest potential for business profit and where your business has, or can quickly develop sufficient work capabilities and delivery performance. The mentioned Capital Goods Company was very capable and successful at Capital Goods maintenance service for both new and existing Capital Goods owners. (This was their so-called "cash cow" business.) They then built upon that success to bridge into offering other products and services in their matrix to those customers, like selling Capital Goods consumables and providing Capital Goods upgradation or decommissioning. (That became their new "rising star" businesses.)

Another important aspect of strategy is for a company to generate marketing, sales and service efforts for improving their penetration into profitable cells in their product/market matrix. The Capital Goods Company used its reputation and word of mouth marketing to generate referral business with existing Capital Goods owners. However, for new Capital Goods owners, it chose to target them through cultivating relationships with Capital Goods retail and construction outlets.

Also, synergies (connections) among the cells in a company’s matrix can be sought and pursued for increased company growth. The Capital Goods company used its reputation in Capital Goods maintenance to add new services of Capital Goods upgradation or Capital Goods decommissioning for appropriate existing Capital Goods owners, yet made sure it did not compete head-to-head with Capital Goods construction companies. Last, obvious synergy came from continuing to service new Capital Goods owners as they crossed the imaginary line to become existing Capital Goods owners.

STEP 3: Craft Actionable Business Strategy from the Bottom 

In theory, enterprise strategies are developed by senior executives and filtered down to create aligned action throughout the organization. But in reality, this process is often quite different—in most organizations executives establish high-level goals and leave the details to individual business units. These goals continue to be pushed down the chain of command to staff who address these goals from their narrower point of view, which can often cause gaps and conflicts. Ultimately, these gaps form the next set of strategic needs—what action the company must take in order to successfully achieve overarching goals.
While most business architects might prefer a top-down approach to strategy development, guided by executives, in many cases this just isn't possible. In fact, many BAs have discovered that they can better align IT's business and technical capabilities with larger company goals by identifying specific strategic needs and organizing these into themes. To help guide this process, there are a few key steps to follow:
  • Facilitate Focus-Group Sessions That Uncover Unmet Needs. Because high-level managers often lack the detailed working knowledge needed to develop next-step strategies, non-executive focus groups can be effective in identifying the organizations concerns and needs at a detailed level. These groups work best with six to twelve people, so they are small enough to be controlled and large enough to generate ideas. To create a productive focus group make sure to find the right participants, and hold meetings in an environment conducive to brainstorming. Pointed questions should be asked, not about strategy but about specific issues and challenges.
  • Analyze The Data To Identify Themes. Look for the output of the focus group sessions to be 150 to 200 individual strategic needs statements. These ideas should be grouped based on repeated ideas, and the remaining statements should be sorted for items that can be directly connected to larger themes. Shoot for fewer, targeted themes rather than a long, undifferentiated list.
  • Translate Themes Into Defined Strategic Imperatives. Once five to fifteen themes have been identified, each one should be given a title and description without using technical terms. The goal here is to translate the list of strategic needs into business imperatives that describe what the business needs to do to reach a solution. After validating themes with the focus group participants and incorporating feedback, executives can be briefed in one-on-one meetings. They should be provided with a one-page summary of the process and a list of participants as well as an explanation of the identified business imperatives. Key questions to get answered include: "Does this make sense?" "Do you agree?" and "Is it actionable?"
  • Once business imperatives are identified, the same three tasks can be used to identify the capabilities IT needs to develop in order to support the business, and to better understand the team's role in the organization.
Traditional approaches are not always best. Because business architecture is still in its infancy and there is little-proven methodology or concrete best practices to follow, creativity and innovation must come into play. Although building a strategy from the ground up may lack the appeal of working with C-level executives, it can be very effective in both creating strategy and developing an interest in the strategy process. Once business executives see effective strategic planning taking place, they will be more likely to get involved.
STEP 4 Utilizing Your Company’s Strategy
Eight tested ways to develop and utilize your company’s business strategy:
  1. Create an "industry and marketing intelligence system" in order to systematically obtain information from your industry, customers, competitors. This will help you in segmenting your marketplace, and in understanding your best and worst product/service capabilities with respect to your competition.
  2. Categorize your marketplace (customers) by industry, customer size or other significant demographic distinctions and then list those categories in order of greatest current and/or potential profitability to your business. Then ask yourself how to a) best pursue buyers within the categories at the top of your list, and b) harvest or divest your business of customer categories at the bottom end of your list.
  3. Follow the same thinking as above with your company’s products/services and distribution channels.
  4. Don’t bite off more cells in your product/market matrix than your organization can chew, for you will spread your organizational resources too thin and be more likely to fail. Chasing after too many "rising stars" can diffuse your organization’s energy. You need to figure out your highest potential marketplace "stars" and pursue those product/market segments first.
  5. Don’t try to be all things to all customers. Pick whether your company can best pursue: 1) product or service leadership (being the best in a product/service category), 2) customer intimacy (focusing on serving a broad array of needs in a particular customer segment), or 3) operational excellence (providing best overall efficiency or lowest cost).
  6. Align your company’s marketing and sales efforts with your strategy. You may choose to set up separate marketing and sales goals, tactics and materials for different sets of viable cells in your product/market matrix.
  7. Make sure that your organization’s policies, processes and people are fully aligned with your chosen business strategy. If they are not, then you may be sending a mixed message not only to your marketplace, but also to your company’s people.
  8. Review your company’s strategy regularly. In turbulent business environments, organizations need to reconfigure themselves (their products, services and target markets) every few years just to keep pace in today’s fast-shifting marketplace.
By thinking through and following the above formulas you can develop a clear and consistent business strategy that can give you a step up on your competition. Also remember that your strategy does not need to be perfect. A reasonable strategy supported by people’s passion and energy has a much better chance for success than a perfect strategy with little enthusiasm and drive behind it.Most strategic plans and intents are swallowed in the execution phase and forgotten.



STEP 5  Driving  Your Company’s Strategy
When your company is faced with a major opportunity or challenge, how do you go about managing it? If for example you've decided that your marketing  system is dated and inefficient and you want to gut it and install a new enterprise wide system, who do you turn to to get the job done? The  Chief Marketing Officer ? After all, the IT department reports to him or her so isn't that the logical way to go? But if you think about it for a moment, the function of  marketing is to serve the customer and thereby be the revenue earner for the rest of the company. Literally every department is a stakeholder in the efficiency of the system that delivers them inputs. How much more efficient would it be to have the actual stakeholders determine what is needed and how to implement the plan? This efficiency, this doing it right the first time is the reason that strategic management teams are becoming more and more popular.

But how do you create these teams? Who should be on them and what responsibilities should they have? Well here are a few ideas on just how to develop and support the effort.

Core team members                                             
A core team of between three and ten members should be selected from senior leadership who are also stakeholders in the project. This will result in a team made up of multiple disciplines whose combined point of view will best reflect the company's culture and focus. A team leader should either be appointed, or elected by other team leaders.

Responsibility
The team should be given a broad objective by the CEO and it should be based on "benefits" to the organization rather than specifications. Using the marketing function, for  example, the objectives may be lower selling costs, better market position, increased customer satisfaction and increased new value through innovation in the promotion. The team then takes those broad strokes, and because they represent every affected department, work out solutions to achieve the objective. Can you see the difference? This is not the marketing department telling the rest of the company "Here's your new system" it is the end users saying "This is what we want a new system to do".

Authority
This is where a CEO has to have courage. The role of the strategic management team is not an advisor to the CEO, they are decision makers. Knowing that their actions will have a direct impact on how the company operates is the secret to successful management teams. Their approach to the task is considerably different and far more focused than if they were simply assigned to a committee to make suggestions. As decision makers, the company needs to invest in them the resources and authority to get their task done

Extended team
The extended team supports the core team by providing additional insights and expertise. The team has as many members as are required by the core group and members may be added or deleted as their expertise is required. At some point, external vendors mat become part of this team. The core team poses the questions and the extended team does the heavy lifting providing the answers.
External members
Complex projects may require bringing in outside talent to assist the core team in performing their function. Brainstorming, for example, is an excellent way to generate many ideas in a short period of time but is most productive when an outside facilitator with experience in brainstorming conducts the session. Likewise with a business coach. If the team bogs down at some point, business coaching can help the team work through the problem solving process.

The CEO's role
While the responsibility and authority for the project rests with the strategic management team, the CEO can obviously have an influence by keeping in close contact and monitoring and measuring progress. Having a close working relationship with the team gives the CEO an excellent opportunity to demonstrate the leadership style that he wants his team to take back to their departments.

The organization's role
Management must be certain to communicate to everyone in the organization that the strategic management team has been formed and that they have absolute authority regarding the project and the cooperation and support of all employees is encouraged and expected. Territorial issues shouldn't be a problem as the core team is made up of senior leaders from each discipline, however having the company in general support the group can only make the process more efficient.


Dr Wilfred Monteiro Founder / Executive Director  of SYNERGY MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATES Mumbai ; works with owner managed companies to help them accelerate performance by offering innovative approaches to business strategy, sales management, organization development & leadership skills 

He can be contacted at email id wm@synergymanager.net
                                                                                                  

Monday, 9 June 2014

MORE THAN TWENTY FIVE YEARS OF THE BALANCED SCORECARD... why do people view it with caution if not with cynicism & suspicion .


BALANCE SCORECARD 


THE RIGHT STEPS IN IMPLEMENTATION

 


MORE THAN TWENTY FIVE  YEARS OF THE  BALANCED SCORECARD... why do people view it with caution if not with cynicism & suspicion . Their main objection is that it does not provide practical guidance for deployment, and some executives view it as a "quick fix" that can easily be installed in their organizations. The fault lies in making it a one-shot adventure when if fact Implementing a balanced metrics system is an evolutionary process, not a one-time task that can be quickly checked off as “completed”. If executives do not recognize this from the beginning and fail to commit to the long term, then the organization will realize disappointing results. Here are some of the key point on data and metrics a critical step in the balance scorecard implementation; I have seen over the past several years that can cause a Balanced Scorecard initiative to fail

The business needs a framework to define and communicate strategic direction and plans. Ensure that the measures you create add value. Metrics need to be relevant and clear. They should be depicted with visual indicators that are easily understood. In addition, metrics need to be collected at the ideal frequency for making decisions, and defined in such a way that the measurement can be consistently applied across the firm, even if their targets of performance differ (and they should). A system that has sloppy or inconsistently defined metrics will be vulnerable to criticism by people who want to avoid accountability for results.

 


KISS FORMULA (KEEP IT SHORT AND SIMPLE)

 

 We had to temper our excitement for creating our own fancy composite-type measures. When we started going through the review meetings for target setting, we found we didn’t have the data we needed, which complicated things. You have to keep in mind that even though the balance scorecard is a big initiative, it’s okay to set basic measures that can evolve into something more meaningful as time progresses. This makes me think of the quote, “Perfect is the enemy of good enough.” Many times, people try to craft elaborate measures—but sometimes it’s best to keep it simple. You don’t want to overburden everyone on the team so they start thinking a scorecard will be more work than it’s worth. In a sense, you have to collect data and be okay with the 75% solution. As you go on throughout the years and collect more data, you will be able to determine the best information to collect and you’ll become better at the measure-making process.

 

EFFICIENT DATA COLLECTION AND REPORTING

A primary reason that companies overemphasize financial metrics at the expense of other important operating variables is the simple fact that systems already exist for collecting and reporting financial measures. Companies that deliberately plan to define the vital few metrics and commit the resources to automate data collection and subsequent reporting tend to achieve good results. Unfortunately, in most organizations, if collecting metrics data consumes too much time and energy, they will not be captured. That is why it is important to prioritize key performance indicators so you can be confident that your investment in metrics is spent on the information that will be most relevant to improving organizational performance.

The mantra in business intelligence is to provide the “right information to the right people at the right time.” Based on the key measurements involved, analysts can dissect the information needs through techniques such as data modeling and dimensional modeling. Those approaches support the analysis, extraction and integration of the right information to support the key measurements. The information provided could be historical, actionable and/or predictive. It would typically reinforce or change the course of action or behavior of the people performing the business process.

 

GATHER THE RIGHT DATA

One major criticism of the Balanced Scorecard is that it encourages an internal focus. This is not as much an indictment of the principle as it is the way companies put the principle into practice. To help overcome this problem, you should ALWAYS start with an external focus – the view of your organization’s  external environment . The goal is to achieve a balance of enterprise level metrics as you assess the organization’s market, shareholders, competitors, employees and stakeholders. Executives will use data about their external environment to assess Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOT). This will then guide them to gaps in their enterprise level metrics. Then, all other levels of metrics are tested for alignment with the enterprise level metrics, thereby ensuring that even internal metrics link to external performance drivers.

HOW MUCH DATA CRUNCHING IS GOOD?

Kaplan and Norton’s balanced scorecard framework recommends no more than 20 key performance indicators (KPIs) within 4 perspectives: financial, customer, internal, learning and growth. Some other experts suggest  enhancing key measurements by removing the traditional budget process recommend less than 12 KPIs. Some recommend the 4 balanced scorecard perspectives plus 2 more related to employee satisfaction and environment/community. Regardless of the approach you select, you should adopt and communicate a strategic planning framework that will fit your business and help identify the key measurements.

 

TIME TABLE  THE PROCESS: AVOID THE OVERKILL

Regardless of the size and complexity of the organization, 12-16 weeks is sufficient time to establish key performance metrics. The exact implementation of the key indicators is rarely right the first time, so it is better to establish a time table  and reserve the opportunity to provide subsequent iterations beyond the initial 12 weeks.

 

With best wishes

Dr Wilfred Monteiro

 

 

 

 

 

.